Administrative vs Criminal: Detailed Comparison
Understanding the critical differences between your DMV administrative hearing and criminal DUI case helps you develop the right defense strategy for each proceeding.
Different Rules, Different Stakes, Different Strategies
What works in one proceeding may hurt you in the other. Each requires its own tailored approach based on different standards of proof, rules of evidence, and potential consequences.
Burden of Proof: The Most Important Difference
This is why you can lose at the DMV but win in criminal court—the standard of proof is dramatically different.
DMV: Preponderance of Evidence
The DMV hearing officer only needs to believe it's "more likely than not" that you violated the DUI laws. This is an incredibly low bar.
Criminal: Beyond Reasonable Doubt
The prosecution must prove you're guilty to a near-certainty. Any reasonable doubt means you should be found not guilty.
What This Means in Practice
Officer says you failed field sobriety tests and smelled of alcohol. Even if you have an innocent explanation, the hearing officer might think "it's more likely than not this person was impaired." Result: You lose.
Same facts, but your attorney shows the breathalyzer wasn't calibrated properly, creating reasonable doubt about accuracy. The jury thinks "we're not 95% sure." Result: Not guilty.
What Each Proceeding Actually Examines
The two proceedings ask different questions and look at different aspects of your arrest.
DMVDMV Administrative Hearing Focuses On
4 Main Questions:
- 1.Did the officer have reasonable suspicion to stop you?
- 2.Did the officer have probable cause to arrest you?
- 3.Were you lawfully arrested?
- 4.Did you have a BAC of 0.08% or higher, OR did you refuse testing?
Additional Considerations:
- •Was the chemical test properly administered?
- •Were testing procedures followed correctly?
- •Were you properly advised of consequences?
- •Is there a valid reason to set aside the suspension?
Key Point: The DMV hearing focuses narrowly on technical and procedural issues. It's not about whether you were actually impaired—just whether the rules were followed.
CRCriminal Court Case Focuses On
Key Questions:
- •Were you actually driving or in physical control?
- •Were you actually impaired to the slightest degree?
- •Is the BAC evidence reliable and admissible?
- •Were your constitutional rights violated?
Defense Opportunities:
- •Challenge reliability of breath/blood tests
- •Present alternative explanations for behavior
- •Question officer observations and credibility
- •Suppress evidence due to rights violations
Key Point: Criminal court examines everything holistically. The jury considers the totality of evidence and can factor in your credibility, alternative explanations, and any doubts.
Procedural Differences That Matter
Who Decides Your Fate
A DMV employee (not a judge) who conducts hundreds of these hearings. They tend to side with the police and DMV. No jury option.
An impartial judge or jury of your peers. You have the constitutional right to a jury trial where 12 people must unanimously agree you're guilty.
Rules of Evidence
Hearsay is often allowed. Police reports can be admitted without the officer present. Technical evidence standards are minimal.
Strict rules of evidence apply. Hearsay is generally excluded. The prosecution must lay proper foundation for all evidence. Chain of custody matters.
Your Rights
- No right to attorney (you can hire one, but state won't provide)
- No jury trial
- Can cross-examine witnesses
- Can present evidence
- Right to attorney (public defender if you can't afford one)
- Right to jury trial
- Right to confront witnesses
- Right against self-incrimination
- Right to appeal
Potential Outcomes & Consequences
DMV Hearing Outcomes
- • No administrative suspension
- • Keep your license (for now)
- • Doesn't affect criminal case
- • License suspended (30 days - 1 year typical)
- • May apply for hardship license after waiting period
- • May need ignition interlock device
- • Must get SR-22 insurance
- • Pay reinstatement fees when eligible
Criminal Case Outcomes
- • No criminal conviction on record
- • No criminal penalties
- • May petition for early DMV reinstatement
- • Eligible for record sealing/expungement
- • Criminal conviction (misdemeanor or felony)
- • Fines ($500-$2,000+ first offense)
- • Possible jail time (48 hours - 6 months)
- • Probation (1-5 years typical)
- • DUI education/treatment program
- • Additional license suspension from court
- • Ignition interlock requirement
- • Permanent criminal record
Defense Strategy Differences
What wins at the DMV may not work in criminal court, and vice versa. Your attorney needs to tailor the approach for each proceeding.
DMV Hearing Strategy
Challenge procedural errors, improper stop, testing protocols, calibration records, officer training certifications.
Missing DS-367 form, incorrect information on arrest report, failure to properly advise of consequences.
If the arresting officer doesn't appear, you often win automatically. Attorneys know how to strategically request continuances to increase no-show odds.
Criminal Court Strategy
Present alternative explanations, character witnesses, expert testimony, medical evidence that creates reasonable doubt about impairment.
File motions to exclude illegally obtained evidence due to Fourth Amendment violations, Miranda violations, or improper search.
Attorneys can negotiate reduced charges (reckless driving), alternative sentencing, or diversion programs to avoid conviction.
Timeline Comparison
DMV Administrative Track (Fast)
Criminal Court Track (Slow)
Strategic Implication: The DMV hearing finishes before the criminal case even gets to trial. This means you can use the DMV hearing as "practice" to depose the officer and discover weaknesses in the case before your criminal trial.
You Need an Attorney Who Understands Both Systems
The differences between administrative and criminal proceedings are complex. An experienced DUI attorney knows how to navigate both tracks to maximize your chances of winning.
Find a Local DUI AttorneyFree consultation • Available 24/7 • Local experts
Related Resources
Request DMV Hearing
Step-by-step guide to requesting your administrative hearing before the deadline.
Two-Track System
How administrative and criminal cases work together as two separate proceedings.
DUI Defense Strategies
Common defense strategies attorneys use to fight DUI charges in court.